I got some of this face lotion as a sample from Sephora and I LOVE it. It's called Primary Care and it's from a company called Cosmedicine. I love the consistency of it (it's light, yet emollient) and it smells clean (not perfumey.)
You should be able to walk into any Sephora and ask for a sample of it. I'm going to buy some when my current face lotion runs out.
PS - They also gave me a sample of a mattifying lotion called Medi-Matte. I don't use it every day, only when I go out at night, and it totally works in keeping shine at bay.